Peyton Buckley: The Trusted Playmaker with the Instincts to Succeed on Sundays
At first glance, Peyton Buckley’s résumé speaks volumes: team captain, multi-year starter, All-American in 2023, and a consistent playmaker for Augustana. But to understand what makes Buckley different, you have to look beyond the accolades. You have to look at the preparation. The discipline. The way he leads, on and off the field. A high-IQ safety with quarterback roots and a mindset rooted in faith, Buckley brings a rare mix of humility, hunger, and football intelligence to every snap. I caught up with Peyton to talk about what separates him, how he studies the game, and why he’s not done growing.
You were a team captain, multi-year starter, and All-American in 2023 — what do you feel separates you from other safeties in this year’s draft class?
I think what separates me from other safeties is my desire to grow. I’m not someone who’s satisfied with position, accolades, or money. I believe God gave me a gift, and it’s my responsibility to multiply the talents He blessed me with to grow His kingdom.
You led Augustana in tackles last season while also snagging three interceptions. How do you balance being aggressive in the run game while staying ready to make plays in coverage?
It comes down to preparation, understanding situations, and having my eyes in the right place. If I do what I’m supposed to pre-snap, I’ll be in the right position post-snap. Football is a simple game when you use the information provided and stay disciplined.
Looking back on your college career, what game or moment do you think best represents the kind of player you are?
It’s hard to sum that up in one moment or game. I believe the growth I’ve made over the past four years tells more about me than any specific play.
You’ve earned All-America honors both on the field and in the classroom. How do you stay locked in and excel at both?
My dad always said you can only control your attitude and effort. I believe if you control those two things, you’ll find success in any area of life.
You’ve been praised for your football IQ and instincts — what’s your weekly approach to film study and preparation?
It varies depending on the opponent. My process is different for a heavy passing team vs. a heavy run team. I focus on run/pass percentages based on personnel, formation, down and distance, and field position. That’s the foundation. From there, I add in common concepts and player-specific scouting.
You were named NSIC Defensive Newcomer of the Year back in 2021 and have grown into a team leader. How has your role evolved since that first season?
My role has been consistent. It’s about leading by example and setting the standard. True leaders don’t create followers — they create more leaders. I want to help my teammates become the best version of themselves.
As a former high school quarterback, how has that offensive background helped shape your understanding of the game as a safety?
It’s helped a lot — especially with knowing how to sit in windows and take away multiple options. Understanding what a quarterback is thinking helps me play faster.
What’s your pre-snap mindset when you’re lined up in the secondary? What keys are you reading?
Most of the game happens before the snap. I consider things like down and distance, personnel, formation, splits, time, who’s on the ball, and where the RB is aligned.
You’ve played at a high level in DII football. What do you say to people who may overlook small-school talent?
The college you go to reflects how good you were in high school — and a lot changes after high school. There’s plenty of talent at small schools. You just have to look.
You’ve had multiple multi-interception seasons — what’s your mindset when the ball’s in the air?
There’s not a lot of time to think. At that point, you just rely on your preparation. You let instinct and talent take over.
You’ve been incredibly consistent across multiple seasons — what drives your preparation and effort year after year?
I’m not satisfied with where I am. I believe I have more potential, and it’s my job to multiply my talents so God can use me to reach more people.
Who’s had the biggest impact on your development — whether a coach, teammate, or family member?
My brother. I almost quit football my freshman year of high school to focus on basketball, but he convinced me not to. He’s also the reason I ended up at Augustana. I wouldn’t be here without him.
What’s something fans or scouts might not see on the stat sheet, but that you take a lot of pride in?
Playing the game the right way. I try to play football with the same standard I live by. Help players up. Speak respectfully. Give 100% effort.
When you’re not on the field or in the film room, what helps you recharge or stay grounded?
My faith. It’s the foundation for everything else. I also love calling family, hanging out with friends, and going hunting and fishing.
What kind of impact do you want to make in an NFL locker room — not just as a player, but as a person?
My purpose is to share the love of Jesus with everyone I meet. That means being the best teammate and person I can be every day — someone consistent and trusted.
What message would you send to NFL teams considering bringing you in? Why are you a guy they can trust in their DB room?
All I need is an opportunity to show my value. I believe I’m someone who’s easy to trust and easy to keep around — whatever’s asked of me, I’ll give it everything I have.
Peyton Buckley isn’t chasing headlines — he’s chasing purpose. With elite preparation, high character, and the production to back it up, Buckley has proven he’s more than a small-school standout. He’s a leader. A builder. A safety you can trust. And for the NFL team that gives him that opportunity — they’ll be getting a lot more than just a playmaker.
Akash Shankar is a Business Economics student at UCLA with a passion for football. He has worked with UCLA Football’s video operations team and is pursuing opportunities in coaching, recruiting, and player personnel.
Instagram: akashshankar_