Denver BroncosNFL News

Tension Rises: The Fifth-Year Option Expires Soon

Jerry Jeudy injured his ribs this week, how serious of an injury is it? Dr. Jesse Morse of the Fantasy Doctors breaks down the injury.
Tension Rises: The Fifth-Year Option Expires Soon

With the deadline for teams to exercise the fifth-year options on first-round picks from the NFL Draft quickly approaching, pressure is mounting. By May 2, teams must decide whether to extend contracts with large one-year guarantees or let go of players requiring high draft investments.

Thus far, only five out of the thirty-two drafted in round one received an offer – Joe Burrow, Tua Tagovailoa, Justin Jefferson, and CeeDee Lamb, and offensive tackle Tristan Wirfs. However, several other potential talents feel like they’re merely waiting for their inevitable announcements, such as quarterback Justin Herbert and cornerback A.J. Terrell.

The increasing challenge involves taking into account both financial stability and team performance. The upcoming year will reveal whether those players who get extended contracts can justify the investments made in them or be a financial burden to their respective teams. Of course, sports fans who make bets in venues like Casa Pariurilor Casino and Sportsbook are eagerly anticipating the outcome.

While the fifth-year option used to be more straightforward, changes made in 2018 and beyond have altered the landscape. Before this new system, the options were tied to draft slots and only guaranteed for injury at exercise. Now, there are four values that rookie players can earn depending on their performance. Additionally, exercising a fifth-year option now comes with full guarantees.

These revisions also come with adjustments in approach for teams trying to make prudent use of their picks. It is becoming increasingly apparent that many talented young athletes might not significantly benefit from applying for early extensions as they sometimes tend to push for long-term contracts after their third year or even sooner.

Injury Concerns and Financial Constraints Impact Teams’ Choices

Making decisions involving in NFL is significant, requiring extensive research to determine an athlete’s value. It involves analyzing the player’s past performances, growth potential, and any inherent investment risks. Also, teams must consider the impact of injuries on an athlete’s performance and their likelihood of recurring. These factors have seen some teams hesitant to extend contracts to players with injury concerns, such as the Washington Commanders and New York Jets.

For some teams, it’s an easy decision. However, for others, the choice is not so black and white. The Green Bay Packers are one team facing a dilemma when considering quarterback Jordan Love. Although he has progressed to being next in line after long-time player Aaron Rodgers was traded away – he has had little playing time.

Love played in ten games with only one start throughout his three years as part of “The Pack.” Nevertheless, they must decide on his fifth-year option before next season commences. It presents conflicting choices: decline Love’s offer and let him become a free agent following the 2023 season – or accept and commit to paying him $20.27 million in guaranteed money for the 2024 season, regardless of his performance.

The large quantity of guaranteed money involved in the fifth-year option process is one factor that makes these decisions so challenging. Some teams may decline offers due to injury concerns, such as Washington Commanders with former No. 2 pick Chase Young – who played just a dozen games over the past two seasons. His high price tag of $17.45 million guaranteed asking too much for his injury risk.

Or take Mekhi Becton from New York Jets, another first-rounder whose injuries meant he had seen on-field action for only one game over two years and would require an expected $12 .57 million in guaranteed money – a significant amount for someone playing so little.

High-Stakes Dilemmas: Commanders’ Young and Broncos’ Jeudy

Not all athletes are at risk due to injuries, such as Kansas City Chief’s running back Clyde Edwards-Helaire. Although he struggled in his 2022 season and played only a third of snap rates, he is still owed $5.46 million for guaranteed money in 2024 – more than rookie pick Isiah Pacheco’s entire deal. The Chiefs may be hesitant to accept such an offer, given the team’s current financial status and the emergence of other players.

Another challenging choice faces Denver Broncos with Jerry Jeudy. The team reportedly seeks trade options before the upcoming season since acquiring him would cost an expected $14.12 million on his fifth-year option alone. 

Despite catching nearly two hundred passes for over two thousand yards and nine touchdowns so far throughout his NFL career being considered good performances, it may not have been enough to justify potential star status. The Broncos are contending with a projected cap of nearly $31 million in 2024, meaning they will have to consider tough decisions that may result in Jeudy being let go.

Financial constraints further exacerbate these difficult decisions, as every organization strives to balance its budgets appropriately while still maintaining top-quality rosters that can compete successfully against other teams. This means reconciling key financial parameters like cap space restrictions with future player performance projections.

The Future is Uncertain: Decisions Must be Made

Financial constraints may make choices difficult despite promising performances for some teams who must decide on their first-round picks. But it’s become clear that choosing between guaranteed money and potential injury risks or financial constraints is a balancing act. Deciding whether players have performed up to expectations while worrying about future costs can be daunting for NFL teams.

Regardless of the choices made by each team, this deadline will undoubtedly shape many young athletes’ futures in professional football – some with more promise than others.

Damond Talbot

NFL Draft Diamonds was created to assist the underdogs playing the sport. We call them diamonds in the rough. My name is Damond Talbot, I have worked extremely hard to help hundreds of small school players over the past several years, and will continue my mission. We have several contributors on this site, and if they contribute their name and contact will be in the piece above. You can email me at

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Back to top button