Should Reuben Bain Jr. be the first overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft?
Rueben Bain’s football journey began in Miami, where he starred at Miami Central High School. By the time he graduated, he had accumulated 77 career sacks, anchoring defenses and driving recruiting interest from top programs. He opted to stay home and play at the University of Miami, where he made an immediate impact.
- In his true freshman season (2023), Bain burst onto the scene with 44 total tackles, 12.5 tackles for loss, and 7.5 sacks — earning ACC Defensive Rookie of the Year and multiple Freshman All-America honors.
- He followed that up in 2024 despite facing a midseason injury: in just nine games, he still notched 23 tackles, 5.5 tackles for loss, and 3.5 sacks. He earned All-ACC Honorable Mention.
- In 2025, he’s back in form. He’s registered pressures, sacks, forced fumbles, and even an interception — while delivering performances that have earned accolades like ACC Defensive Lineman of the Week.
That kind of production — especially given the injury setback — demonstrates resilience, elite traits, and trajectory.
What Makes Bain Special: Traits & Upside
To justify a #1 pick, Bain’s strengths deserve close attention:
- Explosiveness & First Step
Bain displays an outstanding quick burst off the line — allowing him to penetrate gaps or rush the passer before blockers are fully set. Scouts regularly cite his first-step speed as a weapon. - Power, Hands & Technique
He combines brute strength with effective hand usage. He can knock back blockers, leverage lower pads, and reset in contested trench battles. - Versatility & Alignment Flexibility
Bain has lined up in different spots along the defensive front, showing he can be effective from multiple angles — whether as an edge rusher or more interior alignment in some schemes. - Motor, Pursuit & Instincts
He doesn’t give up on plays. He chases down scrambles, backsides, and shows awareness to pivot when needed. - Bounceback & Health
A big question mark was the injury in 2024. But his return in 2025 — with high-effort, high-impact games — suggests he’s healthy, confident, and improving.
Why He Deserves to Be Pick #1 (and What Could Set Him Apart)
To make the case:
- Impact Player on Day One: A franchise investing first overall wants that immediate impact. Bain’s ability to disrupt both run and pass schemes means he can change games from the first snap.
- Rarity at His Position: Defensive linemen (especially edge defenders) rarely get chosen first overall. Taking Bain #1 would signal a team is betting on defense being a foundation. His combination of traits — explosiveness, power, versatility — puts him among the few who might warrant that risk.
- Builder Piece: Every elite offense wants protection; getting a force like Bain helps tilt matchups. He could anchor a defense for a decade if development continues.
- Conditions Favoring Him: The 2026 class may have top quarterbacks, but Bain is already being mentioned as the top non-QB option in many mock drafts. That kind of demand gives him positional leverage.
- Growth Curve: He’s still young. His physical traits, technique, and experience curve suggest more upside to unlock, which is attractive to NFL front offices.
Risks & What He Must Do to Seal the Deal
No prospect is perfect. For Bain:
- Health: The 2024 injury will always be a question. Teams will dig into medicals. He must stay healthy through the remainder of 2025.
- Consistency & Game-to-Game: He’ll need to produce against top competition, not just flashes. Sustained performance, including in big games, will strengthen his case.
- Refinement: Sometimes Bain’s aggression leads him to overpursue or “run past” blocks. He’ll have to refine his awareness and patience.
- Pass Rush Count-Up: He needs to rack up more sacks, pressures, QB hits, etc., to match those elite edge producers. Volume matters.
The Bottom Line
Rueben Bain Jr. is a legitimate candidate for the No. 1 overall pick in 2026. His blend of speed, power, technique, and high-impact playmaking gives him rare upside, especially for a defensive front. If he stays healthy and delivers against top-tier opponents in 2025, there’s a compelling case that he should be on par with — or even ahead of — quarterback prospects in draft boards.
NFL Draft Diamonds was created to assist the underdogs playing the sport. We call them diamonds in the rough. My name is Damond Talbot, I have worked extremely hard to help hundreds of small school players over the past several years, and will continue my mission. We have several contributors on this site, and if they contribute their name and contact will be in the piece above. You can email me at nfldraftdiamonds@gmail.com