Worst Sophomore Slumps of the 2025 NFL Season
The 2025 NFL season has been all about the second years. The Sophomores. The draft class of 2024.
The two leading lights in the AFC are both led by sophomore quarterbacks, namely the Denver Broncos and the New England Patriots. The former of that duo has dual-threat phenom Bo Nix under center. The 25-year-old already ended his side’s decade-long wait for playoff football last season, and now he is looking to go one better by marching them to the Super Bowl for the first time since the days of Peyton Manning.
The Pats, meanwhile, have finally found the heir to the throne that was vacated by Tom Brady five years ago in the form of Drake Maye. The former North Carolina Tar Heel has led New England back to the summit of the AFC East, and they sit on the brink of a playoff return. And if that’s not enough, online betting sites list the 23-year-old as a contender to win the MVP award at the end of the current season.
The latest NFL lines at Bovada currently price Maye as a +400 second favorite to claim the coveted award, narrowly behind Los Angeles Rams veteran QB Matthew Stafford. As well as that, the Patriots are +1200 to leave Santa Clara with the Lombardi Trophy in February, a success that would make them statistically the most successful team in NFL history.
But for every Nix and Maye, there have been other players who have struggled in their second season. Here are the four worst ongoing sophomore slumps in the NFL in 2025.
Look, no one saw this coming—not after what Jayden Daniels did as a rookie. Washington grabbed him second overall in 2024, and the former Arizona State superstar absolutely torched the league: over 3,500 passing yards, nearly 900 on the ground, 37 total touchdowns. He won Offensive Rookie of the Year without breaking a sweat and dragged the Commanders to 12-5, all the way to the NFC Championship for the first time since winning the Super Bowl back in 1991.
It was the kind of rookie season that had people whispering “franchise savior,” dreaming big, and desperate for more. As the 2025 season loomed, Daniels was popping up in early MVP conversations, with an already stacked offense adding Deebo Samuel to its ranks and providing even more arsenal for the young gunslinger to seek out. Experts figured another deep playoff run was in the cards, and let’s face it, who wouldn’t bet on more of that magic?
Then the injuries hit like a truck. Knee sprain early, hamstring tweak, and the big one—a dislocated left elbow in Week 9 that just wouldn’t heal right. He tried coming back, but aggravated it again. Only seven starts this year: 1,262 yards, eight TDs, three picks. Washington cratered to 4-10, out of the playoff hunt weeks ago.
On December 15, they shut him down for good to protect the future. Playoff hopes? Gone. Buried. For 2026, it’s all about keeping him upright—beef up that O-line, maybe ease off some of those designed runs. The talent’s still there, and a healthy Daniels could flip this script in a hurry.
The Chiefs trading up to snag Xavier Worthy at 28 overall in 2024 felt like a steal from day one. The wideout ran a 4.21 forty—fastest ever—and he showed it right away: 59 catches, 600-plus yards, nine scores total. Playing with Mahomes in Reid’s scheme, he was the spark plug they needed.
Heading into this year, everyone figured it would be breakout time. Worthy was supposed to stretch fields, pile up over a thousand yards, and become that true deep threat opposite the vets unseen since Tyreek Hill was shipped off to Miami. But much like in the capital, injuries messed it all up.
Shoulder dislocation right out of the gate, then an ankle sprain, a concussion check—nothing catastrophic, but enough to kill rhythm. Less than 500 receiving yards with just three games remaining is far less than anyone expected. The Chiefs sitting at 6-8 and out of the playoffs for the first time in a decade? Simply unfathomable. But that is the case for both Worthy and KC.
No postseason for Patrick Mahomes and Co. after three straight Super Bowl appearances is certainly a gob-smacker, and the greatest dynasty of the modern era is now officially over. Next year, Worthy’s health is the big if. Get him on the field consistently, sharpen those routes so he’s not just a burner, and with Mahomes back strong, the young star could still hit that ceiling. The former Texas Longhorn is still just 22 and speed like his doesn’t fade overnight.
The Rams taking Jared Verse 19th in 2024 paid off instantly. The guy won Defensive Rookie of the Year—4.5 sacks, constant pressure, locked down the edge. This year, the talk was double-digit sacks, another Pro Bowl, anchoring a contender.
That hasn’t happened. However, it’s not a full slump – more like a subtle step back. Sacks around six or seven, but the win rate dropped (from top-5 to top-10), and more double-teams are eating him up. Run stops still strong, forced fumbles up. Rams rolling at 11-3, division clinched.
The postseason run feels real, and Verse is a big reason why. He has the Rams installed as a +400 Lombardi favorite this term, despite the slump, with much of the lofty billing attributed to the plight of heavyweights Kansas City, Buffalo, and Philadelphia. Focus now is on living up to the billing.
Arizona betting on Marvin Harrison Jr. fourth overall in 2024 made sense—polished routes, Hall of Fame blood. His solid rookie year backed that up: ~885 yards, eight TDs, hints of greatness.
The 2025 hype had him as the next big WR1, 1,200 yards with Kyler Murray healthy. Injuries wrecked it. Concussion, appendicitis surgery, missing games, then a heel/Achilles issue, sidelining him again. Just 594 yards through 15 games, four TDs in spotty action. Cardinals struggling badly—3-11, long eliminated from postseason contention
No playoffs here. For next year: pray for health first. Better timing with whoever’s at QB, tweaks to get Harrison more looks. Talent screams superstar; one full season, and the slump talk vanishes.
NFL Draft Diamonds was created to assist the underdogs playing the sport. We call them diamonds in the rough. My name is Damond Talbot, I have worked extremely hard to help hundreds of small school players over the past several years, and will continue my mission. We have several contributors on this site, and if they contribute their name and contact will be in the piece above. You can email me at nfldraftdiamonds@gmail.com