| P/K | 1 | Harrison | Kiser | Arkansas |
| K | 2 | * Dante | Brown | Fort Hays State |
| K | 3 | Jake | Ford | Ouachita Baptist |
| K | 4 | Jake | Shaffner | Colgate |
| LS | 5 | Drew | Rakers | UW-Platteville |
| LS | 6 | Richard | McNitzky | Stanford |
| LS | 7 | Geron | Eatherly | Tulane |
| LS | 8 | Bailey | Hale | LA TECH |
| LS | 9 | Corliss | Waitman | S Alabama/ Miss St |
| LS | 10 | Tucker | Addington | Sam Houston State |
| P | 11 | Kyle | Reighard | Charleston Southern |
| P | 12 | Marc | Liegghio | Western |
| P | 13 | Blake | Gillikin | Penn State |
| P | 14 | Nick | DiCairano | Endicott |
| P/K | 15 | Gene | Carson | Bowie State |
| P/K | 16 | Cliff | Benjamin | South Carolina St |
| P/K | 17 | Austin | Parker | Duke |
| P/K | 18 | Rodrigo | Blankenship | Georgia |
| P | 19 | Bailey | Cate | Old Dominion Univ. |
| K | 20 | David | Albert | UIW |
| LS | 21 | Joe | DeLeone | Rhode Island |
| PK | 22 | Connor | Martin | Baylor |
| P | 23 | Drake | Higgins | Missouri Valley College |
| K | 24 | Nick | Vogel | UAB |
